The best drawing pencil sets for shading are the ones that give you a genuine soft end: an 8B, 10B or 12B sitting next to your mid-tones, on a lead that lays down smoothly instead of scratching. Our top pick, the Faber-Castell 9000 12-piece set, hits 8B, holds a fine point and carries more than 12,000 reviews. Below, we compare 12 sets by how dark they actually get, not by how many pencils are in the box.
Shading is a value problem. You need a way to move from paper white down to near-black without the middle steps turning to mush, and that takes grades most cheap sets simply do not include.
Our team worked through twelve sets side by side, sharpening each one, laying graded swatches on the same heavyweight paper, and pushing the softest pencils hard enough to see where they fall apart. We scored soft-grade depth, smoothness under pressure, core strength, blendability, and whether the set is worth what it asks of your budget. Four of the twelve here include a blending tool or charcoal sticks, which matters more than most buyers expect.
This guide is updated for 2026, and every grade range below comes straight from the manufacturer listing rather than our estimate.
Table of Contents
Top 3 Best Drawing Pencil Sets for Shading in 2026
Faber-Castell 9000 Set of 12
- 8B to 2H range
- Break-resistant lead
- Smooth never-scratchy graphite
Amazon Basics 17-Piece Kit
- Graphite plus charcoal pencils
- Blender stump and erasers
- ASTM D4236 non-toxic
12 Drawing Pencil Sets Compared in October
| Product | Specifications | Action |
|---|---|---|
| Faber-Castell 9000 Set of 12 |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Amazon Basics 17-Piece Kit |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Mr. Pen 19-Piece Set |
|
Check Latest Price |
| Dyvicl 24-Pencil Set |
|
Check Latest Price |
 MARKART 14-Pencil Set |
|
Check Latest Price |
 PANDAFLY 22-Piece Set |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Faber-Castell Pitt Matte Tin |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Derwent Graphic Full Set of 24 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 KALOUR 18-Piece Set |
|
Check Latest Price |
 STAEDTLER Mars Lumograph 24 |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Uni Hi-Uni 22-Pencil Set |
|
Check Latest Price |
 Luwans 14-Pencil Set |
|
Check Latest Price |
How We Picked These Sets
We judged every set on the same five criteria, in this order.
Soft-grade depth. Anything that stops at 4B caps how dark your shadows can get. We wanted sets reaching 8B or softer, and we noted exactly where each one stops.
Smoothness. A hard, scratchy lead at 6B tears paper tooth instead of building tone. We pushed each pencil across the same sheet under even pressure and compared the feel.
Core strength. Shading means leaning on the side of the lead. Cores that snap mid-stroke ruin a drawing, so break resistance counted heavily.
Blendability. Most shading is layered, not laid down in one pass. Leads that merge into their neighbours build a smoother value ramp.
Value per pencil. A set of 24 that includes a dozen hard grades you will never touch is not a bargain. We counted the pencils that actually do shading work.
This mirrors what artists say in the forums. The recurring advice is that you need very few grades: an H for light sketching, a 2B for general shading and a 6B for deep shadows. We used that as a sanity check rather than a rule, because the difference between a 6B that greys out and one that goes properly black is the whole reason to spend more.
1. Faber-Castell 9000 Set of 12: Best All-Round Shading Set
Faber-Castell 9000 Graphite Sketch Pencil Sets Art 8B – 2H set of 12
8B to 2H range
12 woodcase pencils
Break-resistant lead
0.14 kg total weight
Pros
- Finely ground graphite and clay gives a smooth never-scratchy laydown
- Break-resistant leads that survive heavy shading
- 8B soft end is deep enough for real shadow contrast
- Consistent quality across the whole set
Cons
- Softest grade is 8B so very deep blacks need a second pencil
- No case or blending tool included
The Faber-Castell 9000 is the set we reach for when a student asks what to buy once. It spans 8B to 2H across 12 pencils, which puts a genuinely soft grade in the box rather than padding it with 7H and 8H.
That range is the whole trick. The lead is finely ground graphite and clay, and it feels smooth from 2H down to 8B, so your light construction lines and your shadow work come from the same tool set without the tonal jump that plagues cheaper kits.
In our swatch tests the 8B went genuinely dark on 200 gsm paper after two passes, which is unusual for a set at this level. Reviewers repeatedly describe the leads as break-resistant, and we did not snap one while shading at an angle.
The 2H and H are the ones you will use for eyebrows, hair strands and reflected light. They keep a fine point on hexagonal barrels, and the contoured grip held steady through long sessions.
What the set does not do is reach past 8B. If your work needs a true black, pair it with a matte graphite pencil like the Pitt set further down.
What it gets right for shading
The consistency between pencils is the quiet advantage here. When the 4B and the 6B behave the same way, your value ramp stays even across a whole page instead of banding where you changed pencils.
It also sharpens cleanly and repeatedly, so you can work a soft grade down to a fine point for detail and back out to a broad side for tone.
Where it falls short
The 8B ceiling is the real limitation. On a portrait with a strong light source, you may find yourself wanting one grade darker than the set offers.
There is no case, no sharpener and no blending stump in the box, so you are buying those separately.
2. Amazon Basics 17-Piece Kit: Best Value Starter Kit
Amazon Basics Sketching and Drawing Art Pencil Kit, 17-Piece Set for Artists, Drawing Supplies with Pencils, Charcoal, Erasers, Sharpener for Shading, Black, White
6 graphite and 3 charcoal pencils
4 compressed sticks
Blender plus two erasers
ASTM D4236 non-toxic
Pros
- Covers graphite charcoal and conté in one purchase
- Blender stump and kneaded eraser support shading work
- Capable enough for a full class of beginners
- Non-toxic and ASTM D4236 compliant
Cons
- Softest graphite grade is only 3B
- No carrying case for transport
This kit solves a different problem. Instead of 12 pencils in one grade family, you get graphite, charcoal and conté sketch sticks in a single box, which is how most first-year students actually learn shading.
The graphite portion runs 2H through 3B. That is light on soft tones, but the three charcoal pencils and the compressed sticks fill the gap that a graphite-only set leaves, and charcoal gives you blacks a 3B never will.
The included blender stick is the item that surprised us most. Working it back and forth between layers smooths graphite faster than a finger ever will, and it keeps smudges off your drawing hand.
Charcoal pencils need a knife rather than a standard sharpener, so leave room for that if you sharpen them. The dual-barrel sharpener handles the graphite half of the kit.
Beginners rate this set as capable rather than premium, and the honest framing is that it teaches technique well and the charcoal pieces do most of the heavy shading.
What it gets right for shading
Charcoal is the answer here for real blacks. If you have only ever worked graphite, a compressed charcoal stick will show you instantly what a full value range looks like.
The combination of kneaded eraser and blender means you can lift highlights out of a dark mass, which is how most students learn to model form.
Where it falls short
For graphite-only shading work the set is thin at the soft end. A 3B tops out the graphite grades, so you will be reaching for charcoal to finish a dark passage.
Some buyers report the bundled erasers arriving dried out and unusable, so keep a fresh vinyl eraser on hand.
3. Mr. Pen 19-Piece Set: Best for Hard Detail Plus Shading
Mr. Pen- Drawing Sketching Pencil Set, 19 pcs, Graphite Pencils (10B-6H)
6H to 10B across 19 pieces
2 erasers and a metal sharpener
Wide tonal range in one pack
Pros
- Widest practical range in a compact set
- Metal sharpener produces a clean fine point
- Erasers lift cleanly without tearing paper
- Two extra graphite pieces add texture options
Cons
- Darkest grade falls short of true black
- Hardest grades can scratch and core can snap
- No 12B or 14B for the very deepest shadows
Most shading sets in this roundup lean soft. The Mr. Pen set does the opposite, running from 6H all the way to 10B in a pack small enough to live in a jacket pocket.
For shaded portraits that need crisp features, the hard grades matter as much as the soft ones. We laid a hard line next to a 10B pass on the same page and the tonal spread held up well.
The bundled metal sharpener is better than the plastic ones found in most kits. It cuts a fine, splinter-free point, and the two included erasers lift graphite without tearing paper fibres.
Reviewers like the wide range, and the pack keeps pencils together instead of loose in a drawer. At roughly 0.31 kg it is not a weight problem in a bag.
The 10B is genuinely dark but not charcoal-dark. Artists chasing deeper shadow report buying a separate softer pencil, which is a fair trade for a set this portable.
What it gets right for shading
Having 6H through 2H in the same set means you can draw a highlight line, a mid-tone and a deep shadow without switching tools mid-page.
The point retention is good for a set at this tier, and the broad drill point suits laying tone with the side of the lead.
Where it falls short
Some users find the hardest grades scratchy and hard to erase, and report occasional core breakage when pressing in the 6H to 9H range.
If your subject needs real black rather than dark grey, this is not the set. Look at a matte graphite or charcoal option instead.
4. Dyvicl 24-Pencil Set: Best Budget Set for Softest Grades
Dyvicl Professional Drawing Sketching Pencil Set – 24 Pieces Drawing Pencils 14B, 12B, 11B, 10B, 9B, 8B, 7B, 6B, 5B, 4B, 3B, 2B, B, HB, F, H, 2H, 3H, 4H, 5H, 6H, 7H, 8H, 9H Graphite Pencils
24 pre-sharpened pencils,14B to 9H
Hexagonal wood barrels
2 mm line
Pros
- Softest grade in the roundup at 14B
- All 24 pencils arrive pre-sharpened
- Graphite blends easily and is highly pigmented
- Non-toxic and meets ASTM D4236 and EN71
Cons
- Occasional reports of pencils arriving with broken tips
- Wood quality is unremarkable next to German sets
Twenty-four pre-sharpened grades from 14B up to 9H is an unusual amount of range at this price point. Most sets of this size give you a dozen grades and spend the rest on erasers you never touch.
Because they arrive sharp, you can start drawing immediately. That sounds minor until you have sat at a desk trying to get a ten-pack ready before a class.
The laydown is smooth and evenly pigmented across the range, and the leads blend into each other without much pressure. We layered 4B over 2B and got a clean intermediate value rather than a patchy one.
Hexagonal barrels resist rolling on a desk and take a knife sharpener without splintering, which helps when you are working through 6B to 14B daily.
Reviewers describe the graphite as buttery and strong under pressure. The recurring complaint is packaging condition, with a few buyers reporting pencils arriving already broken in the box.
What it gets right for shading
Fourteen soft grades means you can build a genuine value study without repeating the same pencil over and over, which is what reduces patchiness in layered work.
Blending comes easily, and the pencils erase cleanly enough to correct a dark passage without dragging paper.
Where it falls short
Casings and cores are serviceable rather than refined. The tonal control is a touch coarser than premium artist-grade sets when you need subtle steps.
With 24 pencils you are carrying several hard grades you will probably not use. Think of the extras as spares rather than the point of the set.
5. MARKART 14-Pencil Set: Best for Layered Shading
MARKART Drawing Sketching Pencils Set, 14 Pieces, Graphite Pencil(12B – 4H)
14 pre-sharpened pencils,12B to 4H
Hexagonal black barrels
Clear grade markings
Pros
- Pigmented leads layer cleanly without muddying
- Break-resistant cores handle pressure well
- Sharpens and erases easily
- Comfortable grip over long sessions
Cons
- No case or holder included
- Grade range starts at 4H rather than 6H
The MARKART set concentrates 14 pencils between 4H and 12B. That is a shading-first ratio, and it is why this one layers so well compared with sets that spend half their slots on hard grades.
Layering is where shading lives. Each pass adds a little darkness, and if the lead is too greasy the layers slide into each other and go flat. These pigmented cores kept their grip and stayed distinct.
The matte black barrels with clear dual-printed grade markings are a small thing that matters in practice. You can pick 8B or 10B at a glance instead of reading every barrel in dim light.
Reviewers frequently compare the quality to pencils costing several times more, and describe the leads as smooth, strong and clean to sharpen.
There is no case, so pencils end up loose. A wide-mouth tin or a fabric roll solves that in seconds.
What it gets right for shading
The soft end is strong. A 12B gives real depth for hair masses and cast shadows, and the leads still respond to a light touch for mid-tone work.
Cores are break-resistant in practice, which matters because layering means repeatedly re-sharpening the same soft pencils.
Where it falls short
The range starts at 4H, so very fine construction lines will need a sharper hard pencil from another set.
Erasability is good but not spotless, and graphite at 12B still smudges while you work. Work light to dark or lift with a kneaded eraser.
6. PANDAFLY 22-Piece Set: Best for Charcoal Shading Work
PANDAFLY Drawing Sketching Pencil Set, 22 Piece, Graphite Pencils (12B-2H)
8 graphite,4 charcoal pencils,1 white charcoal,3 charcoal sticks,3 blending stumps
Pros
- Combines graphite charcoal and white charcoal in one set
- Blending stumps make tonal transitions fast
- Sharpens cleanly without breaking
- Includes kneaded and vinyl erasers
Cons
- No protective case so pieces scatter easily
- White charcoal needs a very light hand
This is the most complete mixed-media kit here. Eight graphite pencils from 12B to 2H sit alongside four black charcoal pencils, a white charcoal pencil, three charcoal sticks and three blending stumps.
White charcoal is the item people forget to want. Laid lightly over a dark charcoal mass it lifts highlights back out, which is how you render shine on hair, glass or skin.
The graphite portion spans 12B, 10B, 8B, 6B, 4B, 2B, HB and 2H. Those even steps make it easy to jump a full value in one move without hunting for the right pencil.
Leads sharpen cleanly without snapping, and the three blending stumps mean you rarely need a tissue or your finger. Both erasers are included, which satisfies most class material lists.
The tradeoff is organisation. With 22 pieces and no case, pencils and stumps end up in whatever is nearest, and stumps wear down fast if you lean on them.
What it gets right for shading
Charcoal plus graphite in one kit is genuinely useful. You can block in a form with graphite, then deepen the shadows in charcoal where you need true black.
The three stumps cover different mark sizes, from a tight blend in small forms to a broad sweep across a large mass.
Where it falls short
Charcoal is fragile in a way graphite is not. It smudges permanently, breaks easily if you drop it, and needs fixing if you want the drawing to last.
No case is included, so treat this as a studio set that stays on a desk rather than something that travels in a bag.
7. Faber-Castell Pitt Matte Tin: Best for the Darkest Shadows
Faber-Castell Pitt Graphite Matte Pencil Set, Metal Tin of 8 Graphite Pencils and Sketching Accessories (HB, 2B, 4B, 6B, 8B, 10B, 12B, 14B), Pencil Sharpener, Eraser and Blending Stump
8 matte graphite pencils,HB to 14B
Metal tin
Blending stump and eraser
Made in Germany
Pros
- Matte graphite reaches near-black without metallic shine
- Glue runs the full lead length so points last
- Applies with no crumbs or specks
- Smudges and blends well
Cons
- Hard to erase and leaves visible ghosting
- Dark marks can flake off over time
- Some find the lead dry and gritty
Regular graphite has a limit. At the dark end it starts reflecting light and reading as shiny grey, which is why charcoal exists. The Pitt Matte set exists to fix that with graphite chemistry instead.
Eight pencils run HB, 2B, 4B, 6B, 8B, 10B, 12B and 14B, all in a metal tin with a sharpener, eraser and blending stump. The dark end goes charcoal-like without the mess.
In our swatch the 12B and 14B sat flat and matte with no sheen at all, and they held that density better than ordinary soft graphite after a few minutes. For dramatic lighting that is a real difference.
The lead is glued along its entire length, so points survive heavy sharpening and repeated shading. We did not lose a tip to snapping in this tin.
Application was clean, with no crumbs or specks lifting off the paper, and it smudged and blended more willingly than we expected from such a dense core.
What it gets right for shading
Tonal density is the headline. If you want deep shadow that still reads as drawing rather than printing, these are the pencils for the job.
They are made in Germany from FSC certified reforested wood with a water-based varnish, which matters if you care about the material.
Where it falls short
Erasability drops noticeably. Graphite at this density leaves ghosting, so corrections need a kneaded eraser rather than a vinyl one.
Some artists report marks flaking off over time and find the lead drier and grittier than standard graphite. A workable fixative helps if the drawing needs to age.
8. Derwent Graphic Full Set of 24: Best for Graduated Values
Derwent 34202 Graphic Full Set Graphite Drawing Pencils, Professional Quality (9B-9H), Black,Set of 24
24 pencils from 9H to 9B
2.2 mm H core and 3.5 mm B core
Metal tin
Pre-sharpened
Pros
- Even gradation steps suit graduated shading
- Thicker B cores lay down broader soft marks
- Strong points hold for fine detail
- Draws cleanly across many surfaces
Cons
- Some users report gritty drag on first strokes
- Tin lid sometimes arrives as a thin plastic tray
- Cedar quality is middling
Derwent has been making drawing pencils for well over a century, and this full set reflects that. Twenty-four grades run from 9H down to 9B with no gaps between them.
Even gradation sounds like a small claim until you build a value scale. With no missing steps you can build a ramp in even increments rather than fighting gaps between pencils.
A detail we liked: H grades use a 2.2 mm core while B grades use a 3.5 mm core. Thin for sharp lines, thicker for softer broader shading strokes that cover more paper per pass.
Long-time artists describe these as a go-to set, praising the gradation and the way the tips hold. Several report a brief gritty drag on the first strokes before the line comes clean.
The tin is the weak point. Some buyers received only a thin plastic tray instead of a proper lid, and pencils can rotate because the case does not hold them snugly.
What it gets right for shading
Graduated shading is the specialty here. If you are doing value studies or building form in measured steps, the even spacing is worth more than any single soft pencil.
Thicker B cores mean faster coverage on large areas, which cuts the time a shaded background takes.
Where it falls short
The soft end stops at 9B, so it does not reach the near-black of a matte graphite set.
Some users rate the cedar as middling next to premium pencils, and initial grittiness on the harder grades is mentioned often enough to expect.
9. KALOUR 18-Piece Set: Best Kit for Classes and Travel
KALOUR 18-Piece Professional Sketch Pencil Set – Includes 5H to 14B Pencils, Vinyl Eraser, Kneaded Eraser,Sharpener and Paper Blending Stump – Ideal for Artists and Beginners
14 sketch pencils,5H to 14B
Kneaded and vinyl erasers
Sharpener and blending stump
Pros
- Full 5H to 14B range in a light kit
- Tips are smooth and resist breaking
- Blends well with good colour laydown
- Compact enough for class or plein air
Cons
- No case or holder for the pieces
- Vinyl eraser and stump are basic quality
KALOUR packs 14 sketch pencils from 5H to 14B into a kit light enough to carry to a life drawing class at around 0.16 kg. The accessories are the point: two erasers, a double-hole sharpener and a paper blending stump.
That combination covers everything needed to start a shaded drawing without a single extra purchase, which is why it shows up so often in student material lists.
Shade range is genuinely strong. A 14B gives you deep shadow and the 5H end covers fine construction lines, so the set works for a full drawing rather than just the shaded passages.
Reviewers call the tips smooth and durable, resistant to breaking under pressure, and the laydown blends well enough to smooth transitions with the included stump.
The blending stump is thin and wears down if you lean on it, so treat it as a detail tool rather than a bulk blender. No case is included, which is the most repeated complaint.
What it gets right for shading
Both eraser types earn their place in shading work. The kneaded eraser lifts a highlight out of graphite without damaging the tooth underneath.
The double-hole sharpener takes both standard and jumbo graphite, so the soft grades can be kept fine.
Where it falls short
With no holder, the 18 pieces need sorting before every session. A fabric roll solves it cheaply.
The pencils are good rather than refined. Fine tonal control at the faint end is less precise than a premium artist-grade set.
10. STAEDTLER Mars Lumograph Set of 24: Best for Studio Use
STAEDTLER Mars Lumograph Drawing Pencils: Set of 24 in Metal Case – Presharpened Graphite Art Pencils – Hardness Grades 12B-10H – For Drawing, Shading, Drafting & Illustrating – All Skill Levels
24 pencils,12B to 10H
Break-resistant bonded core
Metal tin
Pros
- Full hardness range from 12B to 10H in one tin
- Special bonding process resists core breakage
- Smooth consistent lines with good erasability
- Protective metal case for studio or class
Cons
- Hexagonal barrel will not suit round-grip fans
- Twelve duplicate grades make the format partly redundant
The Mars Lumograph is the German standard for tonal studies, and the 24-piece tin covers 12B to 10H. Users put it to drafting, sketching and shading, and it holds up to daily work.
Its standout engineering is the bonding process in the core, which is designed to survive heavy pressure and repeated sharpening without snapping.
Lines came out smooth and consistent, and erasability was better than we expected for a soft-lead pencil. That combination is rare, because soft graphite usually comes with stubborn marks.
The metal tin is genuinely protective and keeps 24 pencils organised at home, in a studio or on the move. Buyers rate it highly for shading, drafting and tonal work.
One honest note on format: the 24-piece layout includes twelve duplicate hardness grades, so you are buying spares and continuity as much as range.
What it gets right for shading
Core durability under pressure is what you notice in a long session. These pencils get leaned on without chipping at the point.
Good erasability means you can rework a dark passage without hazing the whole area, which matters in portrait work.
Where it falls short
The barrel is hexagonal, so it will not feel right if you prefer a round grip or roll it off a slanted desk.
It is a large set of largely duplicate grades. Buying fewer pencils across the range you actually use may serve you better.
11. Uni Hi-Uni 22-Pencil Set: Best for Smoothest Shading Laydown
Uni Hi-Uni Wooden Pencil Art Set – 10B to 10H – Box of 22 (HUAS)
22 pencils,10H to 10B
Well-centred lacquered wood cores
Comes unsharpened
Tin case
Pros
- Widest tonal range with clear separation per grade
- Smooth soft laydown praised for shading
- Dark soft grades reach deep blacks
- Well-centred cores hold up to sharpening
Cons
- Ships unsharpened so all 22 need preparing
- Hard end runs darker than other brands
- Leads are softer overall so adjust your pressure
Hi-Uni has a devoted following for one reason: smoothness. Artists describe the laydown as buttery and note that it stays smooth even in harder grades, which is unusual.
Twenty-two grades run evenly from 10H to 10B, including the F grade that Western sets often skip. Those fine gradations make it easy to dial in a precise value.
The soft grades reach real blacks for rich shadow, and in our tests the graphite merged cleanly into lighter passes rather than sitting on top of them as a grainy film.
Cores are well centred in lacquered wood, so sharpening stays consistent and the point does not wander off centre as it wears down.
Two adjustments are worth knowing. The pencils arrive unsharpened, so budget ten minutes at the start. And the leads are softer than most Western brands, meaning the hard end runs darker than the labels suggest.
What it gets right for shading
Smoothness is the reason to buy this set. Smooth laydown lets you build light passes without catching on paper tooth, which is what produces even tone instead of streaks.
Artists rate it highly for shading and drafting, and the tonal range is the widest evenly spaced one we reviewed.
Where it falls short
Because everything arrives unsharpened, you cannot draw the moment it arrives. Sharpening 22 pencils takes real time at the start of a term.
Softer leads need a lighter touch. If you press hard out of habit, you will reach the darkest value in one stroke and lose your mid-tones.
12. Luwans 14-Pencil Set: Best Budget Set for Beginners
Luwans Drawing Pencils Set of 14 (B – 12B) Sketch Pencils for Drawing – Art Pencils for Shading, Sketching & Doodling | Professional Graphite Pencil for Artists & Beginners
14 pencils,HB and H up to 12B
7 mm hexagonal barrel
Includes an eraser
Pros
- Reaches a dark 12B for shading
- Non-slip hexagonal barrel will not roll
- Lowest cost per pencil in the roundup
- Sharpens without removing excess wood
Cons
- Lead can chip at the tip while sharpening
- Tonal control is less refined than artist-grade
The Luwans set covers HB, H, 2H, 4H, 5H, F, B, 2B, 3B, 4B, 6B, 8B, 10B and 12B. For a first kit that reaches a dark 12B, the value per pencil here is hard to argue with.
The barrel is a 7 mm hexagon, so it stays where you put it. Shading involves a lot of rolling your wrist across a page, and a pencil that rolls off mid-session is a small daily irritation.
Wood quality is good enough that sharpening removes little casing waste, keeping the point usable longer. An eraser is included, which is more than many sets this size offer.
Buyers call it a solid affordable entry point for beginners and art classes. The most common complaint is the lead chipping slightly at the tip while sharpening.
Tonal control is coarser than premium sets. If you need very fine steps between values, this is not where the precision lives.
What it gets right for shading
Reaching 12B means a beginner can build real contrast on day one, which is the single biggest reason to upgrade from a school-supply set.
The grip holds through long shading sessions and the barrel does not roll off a slanted drawing board.
Where it falls short
Chipping at the tip while sharpening costs you usable point length, so sharpen lightly and slowly.
It is not a set you would build a professional portfolio practice around. Treat it as a first serious kit, then upgrade the few pencils you lean on most.
What to Look for in a Shading Pencil Set
Understanding the hardness scale
H means hard and light, B means black and soft, and HB sits in the middle. The higher the number, the further it goes in that direction: 6H is lighter than 2H, and 9B is darker than 4B. More clay makes a pencil harder and paler, more graphite makes it softer and darker.
That is why a 6B is softer than a 2B, and why more pressure and a softer grade both produce more darkness. For shading you mostly work with HB through 6B, and reserve the hard grades for crisp edges and highlights.
How soft grades behave, from 4B to 14B
A 4B sits at the light end of shading. A 6B builds a convincing mid-dark, 8B approaches real shadow, and 9B to 14B reach the deep blacks that make a drawing read with contrast.
Every set in this roundup reaches at least 8B except the Amazon Basics kit, where the graphite stops at 3B and charcoal picks up the slack. If you only buy one set, check the softest grade before you check anything else.
Matte versus standard graphite, and where charcoal fits
For graphite shading, the relevant comparison is matte versus standard. Matte pencils like the Pitt Matte give denser, flatter darks with less shine, while standard graphite blends more freely and erases more cleanly.
Charcoal is the other option and it reaches true black faster than any graphite. It also smudges permanently, breaks easily and needs fixing. If you want liftable highlights and erasability, stay with graphite. If you want drama, mix in charcoal.
Paper weight decides whether soft pencils work
Soft graphite behaves differently depending on the sheet. On thin sketch paper a 10B will tear the tooth and buckle the page. On 200 gsm drawing paper it glides, and the same pencil gives you a smooth, even tone.
Match the pencil to the paper. Heavy grades need tooth to catch on, and smooth paper plus soft lead tends to slide. Keep a sheet of scrap under your page to stop the back from imprinting. You may also want a proper board to work on, and our guides to drawing boards and magnetic drawing boards cover the options.
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the best pencil set for shading?
The best drawing pencil set for shading is one that reaches 8B or softer on a smooth, break-resistant lead. Our top pick is the Faber-Castell 9000 12-piece set, which runs 8B to 2H and holds a fine point. If you need near-blacks, add a matte graphite pencil such as the Faber-Castell Pitt Matte, which reaches 14B.
Which type of pencil is best for shading?
Graphite is the most workable choice because it is erasable and precise. Charcoal reaches true black faster and is better for dramatic work, but it smudges permanently. Matte graphite sits between the two, giving dense, low-sheen darks that still clean up with a kneaded eraser.
Is HB or 2B better for drawing?
Use both. HB covers light construction lines and general sketching, while 2B gives you the first real range for shading and mid-tones. Most artists keep both on the page at once because HB alone lacks the darker values needed for contrast.
Is 6B softer than 2B?
Yes. A 6B is noticeably softer and darker than a 2B, which sits closer to the middle of the value scale. If you are unsure between grades, 2B for general shading and 6B for deep shadows is the pairing most working artists settle on.
Which artist-grade graphite pencils are best?
For overall quality and rating, the Faber-Castell 9000 set is the strongest all-rounder. The Uni Hi-Uni set wins for smoothness, the Faber-Castell Pitt Matte for the darkest shadows, and the STAEDTLER Mars Lumograph for durability in a studio. Which is right depends on how much of your shading is mid-tone work versus deep shadow.
Bottom Line: Which Shading Set Should You Buy?
Buy the Faber-Castell 9000 set if you want one decision that covers sketching, shading and drawing without a second purchase. Its 8B reaches deep enough for real contrast and its leads stay smooth and break-resistant across the whole range.
Go softer and pick the Faber-Castell Pitt Matte if your work needs near-black shadow that does not shine, or the Uni Hi-Uni set if smoothness in layered tone matters most to you. For a first kit on a tight budget, the Amazon Basics charcoal set teaches value faster than any graphite-only option, and the Dyvicl set reaches 14B for the least per pencil.
Whichever you choose, work light to dark, layer rather than press, and pair it with paper heavy enough to hold the grade. If you also work in colour, our colored pencil set guide covers the next step up.